Clannad_Man (~Clannad_M@i.am.THE.ClannadMan) has joined #tlwiki
Repiphany: THE
This is a chat log that was recorded on #TLWiki on irc.rizon.net today. Before he came onto the channel, velocity7 of Baka-Tsuki, a site that had unaffiliated themselves with the Clannad VN project, posted these comments made by him:
I would like to clear up some things. This effort has been taken completely out of context.
Everyone is choosing to make the assumptions but no one has opted to reach out to me. I would love to have a proper conversation to explain the aspects of this issue, if you will listen. If you’re willing to talk, let me know.
Some TLWiki-ers joked about inviting Clannad Man into the channel, so flamingspinach invited him to the channel. Clannad_Man accepted. This is the largely unedited conversation between him and the #TLWiki denizens. I’ve only taken out random bits that didn’t matter in the conversation; that is the only editorial decision I made. Credits to TsunNemesis for being my slave (i.e. taking out the timestamps for every line). And flamingspinach for correcting my intro.
flamingspinach: hi Clannad_Man
flamingspinach: so what's up with your kickstarter update
Clannad_Man: What do you want to know?
Clannad_Man:about the update
flamingspinach: your latest kickstarter update says, "Consider this: the international Key community is so passionate about their visual novels / anime that it caught the attention of even the President of Key/Visual Art's! That isn't an easy feat."
flamingspinach: but what actually happened was that some dude from this channel tweeted the link to your kickstarter to @vavasyatyou
Clannad_Man: Yes, I'm quite aware
flamingspinach: so why the discrepancy?
flamingspinach: it's clearly not anything to do with the international Key community's passion that caused @vavasyatyou to become aware of your kickstarter.
Clannad_Man: If the Kickstartr had no backers, few would have noticed or cared, correct?
flamingspinach: that's rather disingenuous
Clannad_Man: So you say.
flamingspinach: you specifically say that "it" caught the attention of the president of Key/VA
flamingspinach: but in fact what it caught the attention of was other western eroge players, such as those in this channel
flamingspinach: who then indirectly alerted @vavasyatyou
flamingspinach: yes, I do say so, and with good reason, as detailed above
Moogy: a lot of the money was from like 2 or 3 people too
Shikiller: >Steven Schoenwald (aka the Clannad Man) has been involved with the Key community for years. He was responsible for leading the English Localization Projects for three Key visual novels (Clannad, Little Busters!, and Tomoyo After)
Shikiller: wow what liar
Shikiller: so you lead the Clannad translation?
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: something else I'm wondering is, why didn't you contact VA/Key before putting up the kickstarter?
flamingspinach: @vavasyatyou said he wasn't aware of your project at all.
Clannad_Man: I can only respond to one person at a time.
flamingspinach: but it seems like when you're going to make a documentary about a company and celebrating the company's 15th anniversary, you would usually contact the company first, right?
flamingspinach: especially if you're saying you're a representative of the international Key community, why have you not communicated with Key at all?
flamingspinach: there are plenty of Key fans who have. Doesn't that make them more qualified to speak for the international Key community than you?
Clannad_Man: First, to Shikiller: When the Baka-Tsuki Clannad project was transferred over to Doki Fansubs, I oversaw it for a time. I never claimed to have led the initial iterations of the localization, responsible for spreading much of its popularity
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: are you 整うing a 説明 to my questions now
Clannad_Man: You're using that terminology to describe my role, spinach, not me. I never claimed to be more qualified than anyone else. I merely took the initiative to act on a proposal. Anyone can do that.
flamingspinach: ok, so you don't claim to be a representative of the international Key community, fine
flamingspinach: that still doesn't explain why you didn't contact Key beforehand
Shikiller: So you claim that you were "responsible for leading the English Localization Project" of Clannad, but you actually just oversaw it for a time?
Clannad_Man: For what purpose? Interviews?
flamingspinach: to let them know that you were going to be doing a documentary about them
flamingspinach: seems like standard procedure, surely?
flamingspinach: unless it was a hostile documentary, which obviously doesn't seem to be the case
flamingspinach: or I guess it's not even technically a documentary about key, is it? it's only about "locations that inspired key".
Clannad_Man: First, there is no reason why I would need to contact them about the majority of the locations which were planned for the documentary. Those locations could be visited by anyone.
Link`: Clannad_Man: why are you pretending to be a major player in the Key community and saying you lead translation projects when no one even knows who you are?
flamingspinach: Second...?
Link`: it’s VERY disrespectful to the people who make these things happen
Link`: and put in thousands of hours into their work
Link`: you’re taking credit for it and it’s kind of awful
Link`: you never answered this question before and just dodged it
Clannad_Man: Continuing on, I was not personally respobsible for gathering interviews. They were not going to be included in the first place.
flamingspinach: I didn’t ask anything about interviews
Clannad_Man: Link, I said I would answer one question at a time
flamingspinach: you sure type slowly
herkz: how about actually answering them then
Clannad_Man:Then what reason would I need to contact them outside of as a courtesy?
Holo|i7: May I interject at this moment and say that I in fact DID appoint Clannad_man to oversee VN translations. He’s no longer leading it, but he isn’t lying when he says he did lead it.
herkz: what does leading it entail
herkz: what did he do exactly?
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: ok, point. So could you post to your kickstarter clarifying that you never contacted Key, and someone else initiated the conversation between you and @vavasyatyou?
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: because there is a guy in the comments who is saying he’s supporting you because you took the initiative to contact Key, which is a misunderstanding on his part
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: it seems like you have some responsibility to clear that up, no?
Holo|i7: Overall planning/scheduling/assigning/pushing people to do their jobs of TLing/Editing/QCing/etc
herkz: so no real work, then
Hibari: ^
Link`: taking all the credit fits then
Link`: thanks for confirming
Clannad_Man: To your first statement, because that would be inaccurate. I haven’t had time yet to respond to everyone’s comments. Dealing with so many angry comments is a challenging thing
flamingspinach: what would be inaccurate?
Holo|i7: I’ll go as far as to say that if I had not assigned C_M to that role, we probably still wouldn’t have release Tomoyo After. The previous leader (before C_M) of the VN dept was very inactive, lol.
herkz: what a loss that would’ve been
Holo|i7: You’re right in saying that he didn’t actually do any TLing/editing, but having someone to lead a project is equally essential
flamingspinach: Holo|i7: sounds like “organizer” rather than “leader” to me, but what to call it is up to the individual project I guess
herkz: in my experience having the translator lead it works best
Holo|i7: Without a leader, nothing gets done, that is a sad but true fact.
Moogy: the fact remains that he didn’t have anything to do with the initial clannad and LB projects and doki hasn’t released anything from those games
flamingspinach: also I think it’s necessary to mention that this is a *fan* translation, in case people get the wrong idea that Key actually had anything to do with the translation
Clannad_Man: See, I don’t understand why you’re making me seem like such a great guy just to tear me down. I’ve done what I’ve done. I don’t picture myself as more than a very enthusiastic fan who thought he would help out
herkz: people don’t like what you did because you asked for money
herkz: literally the only reason
Clannad_Man: Moogy, I’m not responsible for the VN department any more. I haven’t been for months
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: what is inaccurate about what I said? You said my statement was inaccurate. What did you mean?
Clannad_Man: No one contacted Baba about the documentary
flamingspinach: yeah they did
flamingspinach: fuji_fruit did
Clannad_Man: thats not what you asked
Clannad_Man: No one from my end did
flamingspinach: which question are you referring to
flamingspinach: yes, I know
flamingspinach: what I’m saying is, you should clarify that on your kickstarter
flamingspinach: because people in the comments of your kickstarter are getting the idea that you contacted Baba personally
flamingspinach: which you did not
flamingspinach: also, you should link to the twitter conversation you had with Baba instead of just vaguely referring to “a conversation”
Holo|i7: So it all comes down to money, in the end. People are pissed because C_M’s getting donations, lol.
Moogy: it’s against kickstarter rules to offer rewards you didn’t make yourself
flamingspinach: there’s that too
Holo|i7: Yeah, those kickstarter rewards are a major issue, I do agree with that
Clannad_Man: I was in error. I’ve admitted that in my write-up
flamingspinach: otherwise kickstarter just turns into an online shop
Clannad_Man: it is being translated
flamingspinach: your “write-up” being the latest kickstarter update that we can currently see?
flamingspinach: or something else?
Clannad_Man: no
Clannad_Man: something else
flamingspinach: ok, it’s the thing you were telling vavasyatyou you’d translate
flamingspinach: but it is already written, and in english?
Clannad_Man: Yes, its written, and being translated
flamingspinach: then can you post it on your kickstarter so that we and your backers can read it?
Clannad_Man: No. I intend to post the English and the Japanese version at the same time
Moogy: also my main problem is this. regardless of semantic arguments about how you might have helmed the projects once they transferred over to doki, your wording is intentionally disingenuous when you state that you were the head of clannad’s project
flamingspinach: why?
Moogy: velocity7 was the head of clannad’s project, not you
Clannad_Man: because I can.
Moogy: doki’s shit doesn’t matter
DxS: So it all comes down to money, in the end. People are pissed because C_M’s getting donations, lol. – kind of, yeah
DxS: though I don’t see the problem with that
Moogy: also lol 20k dollars to go to japan with a camcorder
flamingspinach: what Moogy said
herkz: who doesn’t love a good scamstarter
Clannad_Man: 1-2 professional videographers, an interpreter/guide, and myself
Hibari: can i get 20k usd too
Hibari: i’ll bring you cake
Blue-kun: harder to figure out than Valvrave’s plot
Blue-kun: brb back to Valvrave
Moogy: only if you give me photocopied madoka genga
Hibari: ok, we have a deal
Holo|i7: You know, if the rewards were removed, and people were still willing to donate, there would be no problems at all (in terms of legality)
Clannad_Man: You know, if you were so inclined to make a documentary on that topic, I’m sure people would offer pledges to your effort as well
herkz: some of us are above scamming people
Link`: ^^
Link`: I have a conscience
Link`: and I’m not going to make believe I’m a huge part of a massive fan community to make $20k and a free trip to Japan
Link`: maybe it’s just me
herkz: i mean, $20k might be reasonable if you had experience and could prove it would cost that much
Holo|i7: If you think it’s a scam, don’t back the project?
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: why have you registered clannad.org?
herkz: uh
Clannad_Man: I’m sure you realized that is completely unsubstantiated.
herkz: not backing isn’t enough
herkz: telling other people it’s a scam is kind of important too
Hibari: ^
Clannad_Man: Because it was open
herkz: Clannad_Man: feel free to prove it’ll cost you $20k then
Clannad_Man: Too bad it was not a scam
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: shouldn’t key have control of that domain?
herkz: lying to yourself doesn’t help us
Link`: If you think it’s a scam, don’t back the project? – but it matters because Clannad_Man was offering unlicensed copyrighted materials as rewards
flamingspinach: and doesn’t pointing clannad.org to your kickstarter deceptively suggest that you are more officially related to key than you actually are?
Holo|i7: And if people are still to donate after you spread your opinion around (that it’s a scam), then there won’t be any problems
Holo|i7: I know Link`, I am saying if the rewards are removed. The legality issue is those rewards
Holo|i7: And the only legality issue
Link`: besides Holo|i7, shouldn’t a project like this raise money on its own merits and not on the Madokas and K-Ons?
Link`: it’s very disingenious
herkz: i don’t have any reason to stop until the project dies and isn’t funded
Clannad_Man: I offered them control of a Key-based domain years ago. They never responded.
Holo|i7: I know Link`, I agree those rewards are not a good idea
Holo|i7: herkz: spread your opinion around the internet then, you might be able to sway a few minds
Holo|i7: point is, if C_M can raise the money without any rewards, there are no problems
Link`: it doesn’t really matter if the Kickstarter comes back without illegal rewards because this whole debacle shows that no one involved is competent enough to run a KS campaign, let alone conduct a documentary and manage $20k in funds properly
Link`: that’s my whole point
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: your behavior is kind of suspicious — why cancel the kickstarter as soon as Baba found out about it?
Holo|i7: C_M already managed to raise half the amount… That in itself is quite an achievement (even though the rewards are dubious, agreed)
herkz: he can only raise money because the kickstarter page contains lies about himself
DxS: so wait
DxS: this magical trip to japan will cost 40k?
Shikiller: 20k
flamingspinach: Holo|i7: two people were responsible for half of that
Clannad_Man: Less than 20k. Kickstarter and Amazon payments costs feeds. So do rewards
Clannad_Man: That’s budgeting
Holo|i7: quite generous people, i know lol
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: why did you cancel the kickstarter only after baba found out about it?
Holo|i7: He explained that in his tweet
Clannad_Man: ^
Holo|i7: as an act of good faith, until he has clarified everything.
flamingspinach: how is canceling a kickstarter an “act of good faith”?
Link`: what’s there to clarify?
flamingspinach: that doesn’t make any sense
Holo|i7: I thought he paused it
flamingspinach: the kickstarter page says “canceled”
Holo|i7: and that it can be resumed?
Link`: Clannad_Man: you were blatantly violating copyright, which means there’s nothing to clarify
Link`: it’s a cut and dry deal here
flamingspinach: He explained that in his tweet
flamingspinach: btw his japanese is so bad that I wouldn’t be surprised if nobody understood that tweet
flamingspinach: if you’re referring to this one
Holo|i7: Actually he didn’t violate any copyright, because he didn’t make any money from it and he didn’t actually post any of the goods to the backers, lol
flamingspinach: “誠意のしるしとして、Kickstarterのプロジェクトを停止します。このプロジェクトは肯定的な意思だけの尽力で行うのを証明したいです
Holo|i7: he has broken no laws
flamingspinach: Holo|i7: you don’t have to make money from something in order to violate copyright
herkz: well he was planning to
herkz: which i’m pretty sure is still illegal
herkz: at the very least it’s against the rules of kickstarter
herkz: so
Clannad_Man: The rewards produced by Key should not have been on there. I realized that. They needed to be removed regardless.
herkz: all of them, really
herkz: anything you didn’t make
flamingspinach: you only realized that after vavasyatyou found your kickstarter?
flamingspinach: or did you realize that before and not say anything?
Clannad_Man: Kickstarter verified the items were OK. That seemed good enough.
flamingspinach: that doesn’t answer the question
Link`: Actually he didn’t violate any copyright, because he didn’t make any money from it and he didn’t actually post any of the goods to the backers, lol – a. it’s violating copyright because he doesn’t own the rights or a license to the material b. it’s against Kickstarter ToS and that’s uncontestable
herkz: kickstarter has been known to not check shit very closely until people start reporting it
Link`: Clannad_Man: wait wait wait you REALLY thought it was perfectly fine to offer unlicensed goods as rewards? really dude?
Link`: ignoring copyright violations, it’s extremely and utterly disrespectful to the creators
Link`: to do that without their permission
Link`:not to mention Madoka and K-On etc have nothing to do with Key or your documentary
Link`: see Holo|i7
Link`: this is what I’m talking about
flamingspinach: well actually you don’t typically need permission from the creator to sell physical artifacts
Link`: Clannad_Man doesn’t understand what he’s doing is wrong and someone like that should not be given $20k to do a documentary in Japan
ammm: Clannad_Man: I have a question. Supposedly this is a documentary about Key. Why weren’t you (or whoever else is involved) planning on having interviews, then? Seems pretty fundamental for me.
flamingspinach: ammm: it’s not, it’s a documentary about “places” featured in key works
DxS: because it’s not a documentary on key
DxS: it’s a documentary on places that inspired key
DxS: apparently
ammm: uhhuh
herkz: i hear japan inspired key
Link`: flamingspinach: you do when you’re using it in a project where money changes hands
herkz: better take a video of the entire country
Link`: even if it’s allegedly non-profit
flamingspinach: Link`: no, you don’t
Link`: which, well, is hard to gauge
Link`: for all we know Clannad_Man will spend $5k on going to Japan and pocket the rest
flamingspinach: the “copyright violation” if any is the fact that he uses key art on his kickstarter page
flamingspinach: not anything to do with the rewards
Link`: Kickstarter has ZERO accountability when it comes to its projects
flamingspinach: the problem with the rewards is that they violate kickstarter’s ToS
Link`: he doesn’t even have to deliver the documentary
Link`: or any rewards
ammm: Okay, different question. Why a doc about “places inspired by Key” and not a doc “about Key”?
flamingspinach: not that they violate Key’s copyright
flamingspinach: ammm: because that requires less actual work ;) but who cares why
shigland joined the chat room.
ammm: i care
flamingspinach: shigland: check it out Clannad_Man is in the channel
Link`: flamingspinach: either way it’s still incredibly disrespectful to the creators
flamingspinach: Link`: I agree, but that’s not illegal
Moogy: it’s also a scam because you can buy the shit he was selling for like 2 dollars on YAJ
Holo|i7: regarding the stuff that shouldn’t have been allowed on KS
flamingspinach: true
Link`: Moogy: if they’re not scanned from his artbooks/setting books
Holo|i7: it’s C_M’s fault for putting them there, but it’s equally KS’s fault for approving it
Link`: which we don’t know
Clannad_Man: amm: spinach is essentially correct in this instance. that would require interpreters and time commitments from Key staff which I assumed would be nearly impossible to get.
Link`: either way it’s a scam
Link`: in many respects
Clannad_Man: It is not. You say so.
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: if you’re really trying to demonstrate your goodwill, you should post to your kickstarter clarifying that you did not actually contact Baba
flamingspinach: because that is the truth, and you admit it
flamingspinach: what do you say?
ammm: But I mean. From a cinematography perspective, how do you make a worthwhile doc about the “places featured in Key games”, given that your target audience are otakus and not geography kicks.
herkz: ammm: you ask for way more money than you need and take random videos with a cheap camera and pocket the rest
Clannad_Man: I’m not a cinematographer, amm. That’s why 1-2 professional videographers were scheduled to be on the production team
flamingspinach: you’re dodging my questions again :)
herkz: why are you going? they should go and take all the videos
ammm: are those video people key fans?
herkz: they don’t need you to tell them how to do their jobs
Holo|i7: herkz: you don’t believe that C_M will hire a cameracrew then
herkz: no, he might
herkz: but i don’t see why he needs to be there
Clannad_Man: Actually no. One watches anime, the other hasn’t watched any
herkz: i’m honestly lost in what he adds to this entire thing
Link`: Clannad_Man: legitimate question: why did you say you’re selling original setting materials straight from the animators if you’re not doing that?
ammm: That seems… problematic, to say the least. Camera crews don’t handle the design of a documentary, that’s presumably going to be your work.
Link`: you’re outright lying there
Holo|i7: so you’re saying that C_M should hire the crew and just set them off on their merry way
Holo|i7: without him
Holo|i7: lol that’s an interesting thought
herkz: no, he should hire someone with experience to make a documentary
Clannad_Man: I said I would be offering OSM’s from my personal collection
herkz: someone who has actually released one
Link`: no, you didn’t
herkz: then it would be way more legit
ammm: it’ll have to be someone who’s both made a documentary and is a key fan
flamingspinach: you guys are all missing the point
flamingspinach: the point is that Clannad_Man’s kickstarter is misleading and should be made less so, and he has given no good reasons for why his kickstarter is so misleading
Link`: The specified original production materials were printed and used by the animators in the productions of said anime; in other words, they are not replica photocopies, but actually the ones used in studio. Some materials may have bends, wrinkles, or fading due to the amount of use received in production, though many appear crisp. Distribution of individual materials will be conducted at random, therefore no one will be able to choose a specific character, background, or object depicted.
Link`: it says right there that you’re offering it straight from the studio
Link`: which is false
herkz: flamingspinach: because if it was the truth, no one would donate
flamingspinach: if he fairly represents his plans on the kickstarter, and they are stupid plans and yet backers pay him money, that’s their loss
Clannad_Man: No, thats not what it says
flamingspinach: but the point is, he doesn’t fairly represent things on his kickstarter
flamingspinach: his plans, maybe
herkz: yeah, fs, they would just be stupid then
herkz: but right now, they’re getting scammed
Link`: Clannad_Man: dude, it says it right there
flamingspinach: but his background and updates, no
Link`: don’t say things that you don’t mean
Link`: it’s unethical
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man has misrepresented things that have already happened and are facts
herkz: i dont have a problem with people donating if the kickstarter wasn’t full of lies
flamingspinach: and you guys are trying to grill him on what he’s going to do in the future?
Link`: “Some materials may have bends, wrinkles, or fading due to the amount of use received in production, though many appear crisp.” especially implies that you’re taking them straight from the studio
Clannad_Man: What I said in that statement, Link, is completely true. You are the one choosing to interpret it differently
ammm: Clannad_Man: I pretty much agree with fs. You need to be more transparent about the product you’re offering and also how the money will be spent.
ammm: And also your former experience doing video projects.
Link`: Clannad_Man: you’re like a GOP politician
Link`: this is rich
Moogy: he also needs to stop lying about running translation projects he didn’t
Link`: you’re saying that I’m misinterpreting what you wrote
Link`: when it’s right there
herkz: but moogy, he would just be some random key fan then
Clannad_Man: yet, you still manage to do so
Clannad_Man: I am just a Key fan
Clannad_Man: why s that so hard to believe?
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: you’re still ignoring my questions.
herkz: i believe that
Link`: you’re dodging the question Clannad_Man
ammm: I’m just approaching this as a documentary kick. It’s not exactly simple to make a good documentary, and certainly not something you can do without former experience.
herkz: lots of people like key
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: if you’re really trying to demonstrate your goodwill, you should post to your kickstarter clarifying that you did not actually contact Baba
flamingspinach: because that is the truth, and you admit it
flamingspinach: what do you say?
herkz: most of them don’t lie about who they are to get money
flamingspinach: answer this
Tomo: excuse me, but am i allowed to say something?
Link`: what does ” Some materials may have bends, wrinkles, or fading due to the amount of use received in production, though many appear crisp.” imply Clannad_Man?
Link`: please answer the question
Moogy: man, this isn’t going anywhere, he’s just going to keep trucking on with his shit reading comprehension and giving evasive answers
herkz: can’t be helped
Moogy: whatever man
Kasuteru: i am totally not logging this
Clannad_Man: Well, it would be helpful if one question was asked at a time. It it easy to say that questions are being dodged with a page of posts a minute
Kasuteru: and showing this to the public
Kovensky: Tomo: why not
Tomo: okay, well
Link`: it’s not very hard to answer questions if you’re not lying to us
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: it’s easy to say that you can only answer one question at a time and then answer them out of order so that the ones you don’t want to answer are left unanswered
Link`: you should know exactly what to say
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: if you’re really trying to demonstrate your goodwill, you should post to your kickstarter clarifying that you did not actually contact Baba
flamingspinach: because that is the truth, and you admit it
flamingspinach: what do you say?
flamingspinach: please answer this first
Tomo: i am the guy who started the initial key 15th anniversary letter project
ammm: Well, he *is* being bombarded by an entire chat room of questions from folks angry at him. Doesn’t make for much of an organized interview.
jp302: he should do one of those things
DxS: i am the guy who started the initial key 15th anniversary letter project
DxS: and?
flamingspinach: that’s it, DxS
flamingspinach: he just wanted to declare that
Clannad_Man: I have no problem saying that Baba contacted me after questions were raised by you, the beliggerent members of the internet. Correct, Spinach
shigland: rofl
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: ok, then please do so
jp302: man, i forgot the websit
flamingspinach: on the kickstarter
Link`: Clannad_Man: what do you have to gain by lying?
Link`: just curious
jp302: that place where people submit questions and you answer them
DxS: what good does that do, fs…
jp302: (very descriptive)
shigland: ask fm?
Clannad_Man: You know, this might be more entertaining if this intire Q&A wasn’t such an obvious setup
flamingspinach: DxS: it makes his kickstarter less full of lies
shigland: or something
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: you think this cacophony is a setup? lol
jp302: yeah ask.fm
Kasuteru: uh
Clannad_Man: Oh, why would I think that?
Kasuteru: clannad
Hibari: Clannad_Man: what do you have to gain by lying? < I wonder…
Kasuteru: you came in here?
DxS: no, I meant this [flamingspinach] that's it, DxS
DxS: [flamingspinach] he just wanted to declare that
flamingspinach: oh lol
flamingspinach: I dunno
flamingspinach: ask him
Clannad_Man: Oh, Hi Kasu
Tomo: why do i want to declare that?
Link`: Clannad_Man: how is this a setup? you’re not answering any of our questions honestly
Clannad_Man: You started everything off
ammm: Seconding jp. I like drama too but we could do this in a more organized way.
DxS: then what was your point, Tomo
Tomo: because this is harming my project
flamingspinach: what is
wilfordx: what project
shigland: send spam to key project i guess
Tomo: key 15th anniversary letter project
wilfordx: lol
Tomo: http://www.key15th.com
DxS: wasn’t he involved with you though?
Holo|i7: Most people in this discussion have an agenda – they think it’s all a scam, and are out to screw the project up, lol. It’s hard to have a fair discussion when the people have already made up their minds (incorrectly) what the intention is
Tomo: sure, if you make it that way
herkz: Tomo maybe you should put something on your website then saying you don’t approve
jp302: Clannad_Man: http://ask.fm/Jonnyprieto i recommend you set up one of these
flamingspinach: jonnyprieto
jp302: also Kasuteru is not shigland (aka fuji_fruit)
Clannad_Man: I know who Kasu is
herkz: instead of having his video and shit right at the top of the front page
shigland: kasuuuuu
Clannad_Man: So, shigland
Kasuteru: kasu is an incredibly qt name
jp302: well all Kasu did did was write a blog entry so people could catch up with what happened
herkz: Holo|i7: sorry for going with the facts
jp302: and translate tweets
DxS: wasn’t he involved with you though? – to tomo, I mean
flamingspinach: 死ねカス >Kasuteru
jp302: so don’t say he “started everything off”
flamingspinach: oh, kastel wrote a blog entry?
flamingspinach: where’s kastel’s blog again
Moogy: yeah
Moogy: https://oppaiisjustice.wordpress.com/2013/10/29/clannad-man-x-vava-doujins/
Kasuteru: i had a blog?
Kasuteru: WOAH
Tomo: well, at some point i will be writing that the anthology and the documentary are planned separately but related
flamingspinach: o
ammm: that reminds me
flamingspinach: I always forget who writes what blogs
Tomo: but well, i am not sure if it really matters that much anymore
Holo|i7: herkz: there are facts and there are incorrect conclusions drawn from the said facts
Holo|i7: but I feel that there’s no point continuing this discussion, lol. people have made their minds up and nothing anyone says is gonna change that
herkz: it’s pretty obvious that he lied about leading those projects so people would think he’s more qualified to do this than anyone else
herkz: and thus got money
herkz: so uh
Moogy: i don’t even care if the project is a scam, really, it’s just that i was around back in 2006-2007 when velocity7 actually started translating clannad
herkz: unless i’m missing something here
Moogy: so it’s incredibly hilarious that some dude no one has heard of comes along in 2013
Moogy: and says he was responsible for it
ammm: clannad’s TL started in 2006?
ammm: that’s like, when WoW came out
Moogy: ammm, i think it was 2007 actually
Moogy: iirc he started it when the anime aired
Moogy: but baka-tsuki was founded in 2006 or something. idk it’s been a really long time
ammm: so ancient
Moogy: but i’ve been around since then, so eyah
Moogy: *yeah
flamingspinach: I have no problem saying that Baba contacted me after questions were raised by you, the beliggerent members of the internet. Correct, Spinach
flamingspinach: Clannad_Man: ok, then please do so on the kickstarter
flamingspinach: no answer
Then00bAvenger: Clannad actually had up to After Story ‘translated’ by the time the anime aired
Holo|i7: yeah you missed fireworks lol
Tomo: if you guys don’t mind me saying
herkz: but TNA
herkz: “He was responsible for leading the English Localization Projects for three Key visual novels (Clannad, Little Busters!, and Tomoyo After)”
herkz: he totally led the projects
Tomo: i think you guys are being dicks by pointing at Clannad_Man and saying he’s a dick
herkz: after they were released
Tomo: not to say that he didn’t bring this on himself
Good_Haro: Hey Mr. Clannad_Man, I have a pressing question for you: what is your opinion of Hadaka Shitsuji?
Clannad_Man left the chat room. (Quit: Getting the Science Done (o^-’)b)
flamingspinach: rofl
Holo|i7: Perhaps he was economical with the truth, but that doesn’t mean he had bad intentions, lol
Tomo: if you guys ask me
herkz: well holo, his refusal to fix it says much more
Holo|i7: you make it sound like he’s gonna do to japan and take a few pics with his cameraphone
flamingspinach: well holo, his refusal to fix it says much more
flamingspinach: ^
Good_Haro: yeah
Good_Haro: he sounds like a scammer
jp302: pretty sure if you run a kickstarter you shouldn’t violate kickstarter’s TOS
shigland: good_haru he googled hadaka and his mind was so blown he closed irc
Good_Haro: from the way he was dodging questions
flamingspinach: I’ve asked him like five times to make it more clear that he didn’t contact baba of his own accord
Good_Haro: heh
Tomo: yes, he made really terrible decisions
herkz: i mean this “He was responsible for leading the English Localization Projects for three Key visual novels (Clannad, Little Busters!, and Tomoyo After)” is factually incorrect
flamingspinach: and he has refused to answer my questions
Good_Haro: yeah
Good_Haro: he sounded like a shady PR man
flamingspinach: now, not that that particular thing is super important
herkz: because clannad and LB had releases before he ever joined
flamingspinach: but it shows how shady he is
Tomo: i was told only told there would be a documentary and a kickstarter for it, and never knew about it in detail
Tomo: but
herkz: not to mention the people who led those two projects are still around
herkz: and still leading them
jp302: unless he was arguing “Projects cannot resell items or offer rewards not produced by the project or its creator.” didn’t apply because it was his personal collection and i missed it
ammm: joining a channel full of people who want to tear me a new one and taking questions from them all at once is what i would do were i PRing for my kickstarter project
jp302: idk what Link` was getting at
Holo|i7: you know, I loled at his KS when i first saw it, but only because i thought 20k was a ridiculous goal
flamingspinach: Link` was just being dumb
Holo|i7: not because I thought he was getting a free trip to japan, or doing a runner with the money
flamingspinach: there’s a way to grill people correctly and a way to grill them ineffectually
Kovensky: never knew of any of this until baba happened
herkz: in fact, someone joined the LB channel and was mad that clannad_man was lying and saying he ran the project
Tomo: holo, i have to say, i found it ridiculous too, and it didn’t even seem like he was going to succeed
Tomo: seeing that he exhausted his higher priced tiers
Holo|i7: But let’s say that hypothetically he did intend to scam you guys
Holo|i7: certainly if I was him, I would probably run without about 10k
Good_Haro: well I think the biggest scam aspect really was in the rewards
Holo|i7: much easier goal to reach
Kovensky: it’s also not uncommon for kickstarters to get high value backers that suddenly disappear one or two days before the deadline
Good_Haro: obviously he was using big names like Madoka and shit to get money out of dumb people who don’t know better
Good_Haro: and to make the project more legitimate
ammm: i think you’d get into legal trouble if you just take the money and don’t give backer gifts
jp302: i don’t really want to call it a ‘scam’, i just think either his backers didn’t realize what they were getting and thought he was making a real key documentary, or were in it for the rewards
Good_Haro: looking like he has some kind of personal connection with the studios
ammm: what KS scammers mostly do is take the money and make a cheap product that sort of fills the requirements
flamingspinach: jp302: same
Good_Haro: idk I think he intentionally mislead people
Good_Haro: I think that qualifies?
jp302: yeah, you can’t deny that he lied about shit
herkz: how is lying to get more money not a scam
Tomo: i actually agree with most of what you guys are talking about, aside from the scam part
Good_Haro: and I think he was fully cognizant of the fact that he was lying
jp302: because the lies were tangential to the objective of the KS
Good_Haro: like this wasn’t some accidental oversight
Good_Haro: he was misrepresenting himself
Kovensky: anyway, assuming ignorance rather than malice, what makes this get weirder is the lack of communication
Good_Haro: and the project
ammm: i think he had good intentions and is just very incompetent
herkz: but the only reason people donated to him is because he lied about who he was
Good_Haro: I mean he does a few things
herkz: why would people donate to some random guy?
Good_Haro: first he misrepresents his importance in the community
shigland: clanad man was in high authority in japan so he doesn’t even need to contact key staff to get an interview with them
Holo|i7: he may have been economical with the truth, but the intention wasn’t to scam your money, it was simply getting money for his documentary. At the end of the day, his intentions were good
jp302 checks the dictionary
Holo|i7: that you can’t deny
Good_Haro: and then he uses those rewards to make it look like
Good_Haro: he’s related to the creators somehow
Kovensky: whether that’s good or not is besides the point
herkz: he wasn’t economical with the truth
herkz: he lied
herkz: wtf
Good_Haro: yeah
herkz: stop saying that
Good_Haro: also idk how you can argue his intentions were good
Good_Haro: what’s so good about a stupid documentary
shigland: he just wanted 20k ok
Tomo: my opinion is that, yeah, he may be doing a bad job at all that stuff, but he’s just trying to do something in good faith
Good_Haro: it’s not even a good idea for a documentary
flamingspinach: I’m still pissed off by this comment
flamingspinach: I’m glad that you got in touch with the company. Unless you have explicitly stated this is in no way related to the company, I was in no way being able to truly support this project. I know the cancellation will disappoint many, but I will let you know that you have won over my support with this move.
flamingspinach: he totally didn’t get in touch with the company
Good_Haro: yeah
ammm: good intentions==honestly wanting to make a product
flamingspinach: and he still hasn’t explicitly stated that this is in no way related to the company
jp302: “A scam or confidence trick is an attempt to defraud a person or group by gaining their confidence.” i guess you can argue that he created false ‘confidence’, but there’s no way to know if he intended fraud
Good_Haro: I don’t think he really wanted to make a doc
flamingspinach: and this poor backer is paying him money
Holo|i7: I’ve known him a bit longer than you have, I guess. That guy is crazy about Key.
Good_Haro: I think he wanted to go to japan
ammm: incompetent==having 0 idea how to go about it and doing a lot of dumb stuff
flamingspinach: that is not cool
Good_Haro: and I think the doc
Good_Haro: was an excuse
ammm: well, he could’ve wanted to do both
flamingspinach: Holo|i7 and Tomo I don’t know how you can defend the above
Holo|i7: Someone else doing it, I’d think they just want a holiday to japan
jp302: but yeah
Holo|i7: but with C_M, I do think his intention wasn’t to get a free trip to japan.
Tomo: i am not trying to defend that, because that is just sad
Good_Haro: idk
Holo|i7: I might be wrong, you might be wrong.
Shikiller: it doesn’t matter how much he loves Key, he shouldn’t take credit for another person’s work
Holo|i7: no one knows that, but C_M, I guess.
Good_Haro: lemme put it this way I think it’d be neat to blog about locations from Hadaka Shitsuji
Shikiller: fuck him
Good_Haro: but if I put up a KS like this
Good_Haro: it would definitely be more about a way to get a free trip to japan
shigland: Also, any information present in the project would probably already have been posted in japanese. 20k for images of backgrounds use is retarded.
Kovensky: Good_Haro: you really liked hadaka shitsuji, didn’t you
Good_Haro: even if I had genuinely intended to do the KS
Good_Haro: I did
Good_Haro: lol
flamingspinach: it doesn’t matter how much he loves Key, he shouldn’t take credit for another person’s work
flamingspinach: yes
Holo|i7: If it was for a free trip to Japan, he doesn’t need 20k
Holo|i7: 5k is more than enough
flamingspinach: Holo|i7: did you see the comment I pasted
Good_Haro: maybe he’s greedy
Holo|i7: yeah, he shouldn’t take credit, I agree
Tomo: basically
Good_Haro: and the fact that he doesn’t lay out costs
Good_Haro: is a bit suspect
flamingspinach: no I don’t mean shikiller’s comment
flamingspinach: I mean the comment from some backer >Holo|i7
Good_Haro: I can eat it for stuff like Trigger’s kickstarter because they’re a known quantity
Hibari: Holo|i7, people are greedy
Kovensky: ” I’m glad that you got in touch with the company. Unless you have explicitly stated this is in no way related to the company, I was in no way being able to truly support this project. I know the cancellation will disappoint many, but I will let you know that you have won over my support with this move.”
Good_Haro: but some random dude
flamingspinach: yeah that
Good_Haro: who’s never produced a documentary before?
herkz: well trigger has actually released stuff
flamingspinach: that comment
Good_Haro: yeah exactly
Hibari: that comment is autism³
ammm: this is a really big issue with his kickstarter btw
ammm: he’s never done a documentary before
Tomo: my opinion is that, yes, he misrepresented a lot of stuff without ever telling me anything, and has an ego that to this day i don’t understand how it is possible for someone to possess, but it’s kind of sad that you guys keep calling him out even though he had good intentions
shigland: What would his documentary even cover?
flamingspinach: good intentions don’t mean shit
flamingspinach: the result is that people are getting deceived
Tomo: in a way, beating a dead horse even, just because we all know what happened there
shigland: shit that’s already been posted millions of times?
Kovensky:the bigger problem is not what he did
Holo|i7: that comment from a backer is fair enough
Kovensky: it’s what he’s not doing
flamingspinach: Tomo: we do, but the backers don’t
flamingspinach: that’s the whole point
shigland: He’s not even going to contact the people who worked on the games
shigland: what kind of documentary is that
Tomo: i definitely had to say, though
flamingspinach: who cares what the documentary is really about, as long as he makes it clear on the kickstarter so people don’t pay money for something they’re not going to get
Tomo: i was kind of pissed off when he started it
Holo|i7: people keep saying he’ll make a shit documentary without knowing the type of person he is
Tomo: have*
flamingspinach: I don’t care if it’s a documentary about his bathtub, as long as he doesn’t lie on his KS page about it
shigland: lol
herkz: pretty much
Kovensky: is “leader of these translation projects” technically a lie btw?
herkz: people can waste their money on a shit documentary
herkz: as long as they aren’t lied to on the kickstarter page
herkz: Kovensky, yes
Raide: I was kind of overjoyed when I saw the KS page, since it’ll cause pain for KEYfags and hilarity for all
Shikiller: it is a lie, yes
flamingspinach: Kovensky: there are straight out lies and then there are deceptive and misleading phrasings
shigland: it’s a lie no matter how you look at it
Kovensky: yes, it’s misleading
Holo|i7: he was in charge of the doki VN dept at some point, so he was in charge of Tomoyo After
Tomo: i have to agree that he didn’t lead any of them
flamingspinach: he was a leader of something
Kovensky: but, in Doki’s translation project, is he the one leading it?
Holo|i7: but not really of Clannad and LB, because his successor is leading those
flamingspinach: but not of anything which actually produced a fan translation, apparently
flamingspinach: yeah
herkz: the leader of the clannad project is velocity7 and the leader of the LB project are the people in #fluffy (not to mention they’re listed on the tlwiki page)
shigland: clannad man is the secret leader
Kovensky: ic
Tomo: holo, if you ask me, i sometimes questioned why he didn’t do anything at all
Kovensky: it could be one of those *technical* truths if he happened to actually (at least in name) lead them back when he wrote the KS page
Holo|i7: he was economical with the truth
Holo|i7: he didn’t outright tell a lie
Raide: he’s like the equivalent of Idea Man in EVN development scene, those who throw around ideas and look for writers / artist
Good_Haro: no he pretty much lied
Raide: and then feeling like he did 90% of the work
herkz: funny part is, he’s not even involved with that anymore
Tomo: though i would be wrong if i don’t point out he did put a lot of momentum in the original key15th project
Good_Haro: that’s not like just leaving out things
Holo|i7: yeah, he’s not involved anymore
Holo|i7: that’s true
herkz: well the kickstarter is in present tense
herkz: so
Raide: organizer =! leader
Good_Haro: anyway it’s sad that your only defense is a dumb semantic argument
herkz: it should say he was formely the leader or something
Good_Haro: and a really weak one at that
Kovensky: lol
Kovensky: yeah, I was just wondering if there was at least a semantic argument for it
Kovensky: or if it was entirely wrong
herkz: the truth is he was the leader of the tomoyo after project (whatever that means)
herkz: the rest is completely wrong
Tomo: well, i was on the tomoyo after project
Kovensky: also, isn’t Doki well-known for not being good at translation :F
Good_Haro: herkz: the rest is completely wrong <– aka he lied
herkz: i dont think that matters
Holo|i7: propaganda that you hear
herkz: is it propaganda if it used to be true?
herkz: i think people just don't care to check anymore
Holo|i7: some of our stuff is bad, some is good
Holo|i7: not everything is good
Good_Haro: what does propaganda have to do with anything
herkz: nothing
Kovensky: Good_Haro: he's replying to my comment about Doki being bad
Holo|i7: yeah
Good_Haro: I still don't see how that constitutes propaganda
Good_Haro: but okay lol
Holo|i7: some TLs are good, some aren't so good
Kovensky: lol
Kovensky: I haven't seen anything Doki so I can't confirm anything
Holo|i7: well saying that everything we do is bad is untrue, therefore is propaganda, lol
Holo|i7: but that's beside the point
Link`: re: people who are saying it wasn't a scam and Clannad Man is just incompetent but well-intentioned, considering how much he lied, isn't the onus on him to prove he isn't a scammer in some way?
Kovensky: though as of late I've been trying to ignore subtitles <_<
Kovensky: (or only use it as vocab crutch)
Good_Haro: Holo|i7: well saying that everything we do is bad is untrue, therefore is propaganda, lol <– I think you need to look up what that word means
herkz: Link`: him fixing that stuff on the kickstarter page woukd prove he's not
Holo|i7: Link`: I think final verdict should be reserved til we see his letter to baba
herkz: yet he hasn't changed anything
Kovensky: herkz: well, he suspended the KS
herkz: the page is still there
herkz: unaltered
herkz: so
Kovensky:oic
Holo|i7: give the dude some time, lol
herkz: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/ibhmc/key15th-a-visual-documentary
herkz: it would take about 2 minutes to fix it
herkz: by my estimation
Holo|i7: it's not like he's off to the bank to withdraw the 10k and jetting off to the bahamas
Good_Haro: probably less even!
herkz: change the stuff about him being the leader
herkz: delete all the rewards
herkz: done
Link`: Holo|i7: it's like saying "well I guess this dude who stole my friend's car is a fine chap because no one's proven without reasonable doubt that he didn't steal it"
Tomo: i haven't ever done anything on kickstarter, so i wouldn't know, but can you actually change something that's supposed to represent a pitch after you made that pitch?
Link`: Clannad Man should be the one proving to us that he's legit
Link`: not vice versa
Good_Haro: also he totally had good intentions in stealing that car if he did steal it and I'm not saying he did
flamingspinach: Tomo: absolutely
Link`: Tomo: yes
Tomo: okay
Holo|i7: Actually he should be proving to his backers that he's legit
shigland: lol G_H
Kovensky: Tomo: I think the only thing you can't change is your funding goal
herkz: how do you know we're not potential backers
Good_Haro: well we're part of the community that could theoretically be potential backers
Tomo: wait, so you can change rewards too?
herkz: yes
Good_Haro: sorta
shigland: And anyone who says he did steal it is spewing propaganda
Tomo: because i would be pissed if i pledge for something then it got swapped with something else
Good_Haro: you can't change reward tiers that people have already pledged on
Repiphany:You can't delete rewards if people have pledged to them
shigland: lol
ammm: i only pledge for music projects on KS
Holo|i7: I'd have to seriously question your common sense if you gave money to a KS which you blatantly think is a scam
ammm: /hip
Good_Haro: but technically nothing you promise on KS is like
Good_Haro: legally enforcable
herkz: how would they know it's a scam
Good_Haro: from what I understand
herkz: why do you think we're making such a big deal out of it
Holo|i7: [herkz] how do you know we’re not potential backers
shigland: herkz is the #1 key fan if you didn’t know
herkz: never know, some of us might donate to a key documentary
Holo|i7: definitely not to this one though
herkz: we can’t force him to fix his page, but if he doesn’t i’m pretty sure his shitty reputation will keep following him for a long time
nice post key fans sux happy now???
Pingback: Omissions, Misleading, and Outright Lies | Kortir
More than a week later and that was an absolutely horrible read. I especially loved the last third after C_M left.
Pingback: “Key 15th: A Visual Documentary” canceled after encounter with President of Visual Art’s | VNTLS News